Summary
The patient in this case was a 55-year-old male who was involved in a motorcycle accident. Following recovery from multiple orthopedic injuries sustained in the accident, the patient was referred for outpatient physical therapy for treatment of a traumatic brachial plexus injury affecting the right upper extremity.
The insured was a second-year Doctor of Physical Therapy (DPT) student, assigned to her first physical therapy (PT) clinical rotation at an outpatient PT clinic where the incident occurred. The clinical instructor (CI), a licensed physical therapist who also owned the practice, had planned to orient the student to the clinic's policies, procedures, treatment protocols and equipment, as this was her first day of the rotation. However, unexpected staffing shortages and administrative responsibilities prevented him from completing the planned orientation. The CI advised the student that he would assign her minor patient care activities and that she could ask a PT aide for assistance, if he was unavailable.
On the day of the incident, the CI performed the patient's initial evaluation and identified right arm motor weakness as well as significantly impaired sensation. His usual practice was to document examination findings concurrently; however, because he was late for a staff meeting, he deferred entering the findings into the healthcare information record until later that day.
The plan of care included therapeutic exercise, superficial heat and manual therapy to address limitations in range of motion, strength and functional mobility. Before leaving the treatment area to attend the staff meeting, the CI instructed the student to initiate treatment by applying a hot pack and indicated that he would return to conduct the remainder of the therapy session. He did not communicate the patient's sensory impairment to the student, specify the duration or other parameters for the heat application, including providing a skin barrier, or discuss the need for skin assessment and monitoring because of the patient's impaired ability to perceive temperature. He also did not verify that the student had reviewed the patient's clinical history or was familiar with the patient’s diagnosis.
After the CI left the treatment area, the student wrapped the hot pack in a towel and applied it to the patient's affected arm. Because the student was uncertain how long the heat should remain in place, she assumed that it should remain until the CI returned. She did not seek clarification regarding the treatment duration. The patient reported no discomfort during the heat application. When the CI returned and removed the hot pack, he observed significant erythema and skin blistering. Because of his impaired sensation, the patient had not perceived that the temperature had become excessive. Additionally, the CI noted that the student had only used one towel to wrap the hot pack, which was not sufficient in protecting the skin, as opposed to the multiple layers that he would have recommended. The patient was transferred to the local emergency department where he was diagnosed with a deep partial-thickness thermal burn, with areas of devitalized tissue that subsequently required wound care and debridement. The patient was left with permanent scarring and did not return to his functional baseline regarding the use of his dominant right arm/hand.
Risk Control Comments
Plaintiff’s Allegations and Experts:
The plaintiff alleged that the CI failed to provide appropriate supervision of the student and failed to communicate clinically significant findings regarding the patient's impaired sensation. The plaintiff further asserted that the student had not received sufficient orientation regarding the safe use of clinic equipment and that the CI improperly delegated care without verifying competency.
The plaintiff's PT expert opined that the patient's known sensory deficits warranted additional precautions for the application of superficial heat, including appropriate skin assessment and monitoring and that these precautions would have prevented the burn. A wound-care expert testified as to the extent of the burn, scarring, subsequent treatment and the potential permanency and loss of functionality of the affected extremity. The plaintiff claimed that he would be unable to return to his baseline functional status regarding activities of daily living due to the permanent scarring and tissue damage of his right forearm and hand and that he would no longer be able to work as a mechanic.
Defense Experts:
The defense retained a PT expert to evaluate the applicable standard of care, including the supervision of the DPT student and the use of a thermal modality.
The expert was critical of the student's failure to seek clarification when she was uncertain about the duration of the heat application. The expert was unable to support the care provided by the supervising CI and identified several significant defense challenges:
- Inadequate student orientation, competency validation and delegation. The student participated in patient care before completion of the planned clinical orientation and without documented validation of her ability to safely use the thermal modality.
- Failure to communicate patient information and risk factors. The CI did not inform the student of the patient's neuropathy and diminished ability to perceive temperature, an examination finding directly related to the intervention. The student was not provided specific parameters for the thermal application, including treatment duration, monitoring expectations, skin assessment or criteria for discontinuing treatment. In addition, the CI's exam findings were not entered into the healthcare information record, thereby reducing the availability of clinically significant information to other members of the healthcare team.
- Lack of an established clinical education process. The practice lacked a formal process for orienting and precepting students, assessing competency and determining appropriate levels of supervision for assigned treatment activities.
Resolution:
Based upon the above-noted defense challenges, the claim was resolved on behalf of the DPT student through mediation with a total incurred amount exceeding $190,000.
Risk Control Recommendations for PT/DPT Students
Consider the following strategies to support patient safety and role clarification during clinical education:
- Self-advocate for appropriate supervision by identifying competency deficits and communicating those limitations to the CI. Students should feel empowered to request clarification or additional supervision when treatment instructions are unclear or they are unfamiliar with an intervention or equipment. When supervision is unavailable, consider pausing care and requesting appropriate clinical guidance before proceeding.
- Discuss supervision expectations with the CI at the outset of a new clinical rotation, including when the CI is expected to be physically present and supervisory coverage for times when the CI is not immediately available. Students can discuss supervision expectations with their CI at the beginning and throughout the clinical rotation as their skills and responsibilities evolve.
- Review relevant patient information before initiating treatment in order to become familiar with the diagnosis, plan of care, precautions, contraindications, and clinically significant findings relevant to the assigned intervention.
- Communicate patient-safety concerns promptly to the CI. Unexpected symptoms, changes in condition, abnormal skin findings, patient complaints, or uncertainty regarding treatment should prompt communication with the CI before treatment continues.
- Understand role delineation and who may provide supervision and clinical direction. Students may work alongside physical therapist assistants, technicians, aides, and other staff, and should understand the respective roles of these individuals, but limit supervision to the assigned CI.
Risk Control Recommendations for Clinical Instructors:
- Provide direct supervision and remain immediately available for questions when serving in the role of a CI.
- Consider whether the student's knowledge and experience are appropriate for the intervention being assigned and whether the level of supervision is aligned with their competency.
- Document student orientation to policies, equipment, emergency procedures, and treatment protocols.
General Risk Control Recommendations for Physical Therapists
- Document patient care assessments, observations, communications and actions in an objective, timely and complete manner. Refrain from documenting subjective opinions or conclusions, or inappropriate statements about patients or other members of the healthcare team.
- Be aware of the high risk of burns from commonly used treatments, such as hot packs, cold/ice packs and electrotherapy. Ensure that each of these treatments is clinically appropriate and that there are no clinical contraindications for their use.
- Evaluate and document each patient’s skin integrity, neurological status, and ability to perceive pain and convey risk factors to all staff members involved in the patient’s care. Closely monitor patients during treatment, including frequent skin checks.
- Inspect and/or test equipment prior to patient use, documenting safety checks and preventive maintenance for all equipment per manufacturer guidelines and facility policies.
- Sequester equipment involved in a patient complication or injury and refrain from repairing it or releasing it to the manufacturer prior to discussing with legal counsel.
Disclaimer
The information, examples and suggestions presented in this material have been developed from sources believed to be reliable as of the date they are cited, but they should not be construed as legal or other professional advice. CNA, Aon, Affinity Insurance Services, Inc., NSO, or HPSO accepts no responsibility for the accuracy or completeness of this material and recommends the consultation with competent legal counsel and/or other professional advisors before applying this material in any particular factual situations. This material is for illustrative purposes and is not intended to constitute a contract. Please remember that only the relevant insurance policy can provide the actual terms, coverages, amounts, conditions and exclusions for an insured. All products and services may not be available in all states and may be subject to change without notice. Certain coverages may be provided by a surplus lines insurer. Surplus lines insurers do not generally participate in state guaranty funds, and insureds are therefore not protected by such funds. The claims examples are hypothetical situations based on actual matters. Settlement amounts are approximations. Certain facts and identifying characteristics were changed to protect confidentiality and privacy. Any references to non-CNA, non-Aon, AIS, NSO, and HPSO websites are provided solely for convenience, and CNA, Aon, AIS, NSO and HPSO disclaim any responsibility with respect to such websites. “CNA” is a registered trademark of CNA Financial Corporation. Certain CNA Financial Corporation subsidiaries use the “CNA” trademark in connection with insurance underwriting and claims activities. This material is not for further distribution without the express consent of CNA. Copyright © 2026 CNA. All rights reserved.
Healthcare Providers Service Organization is a registered trade name of Affinity Insurance Services, Inc., a licensed producer in all states (TX 13695); (AR 100106022); in CA, MN, AIS Affinity Insurance Agency, Inc. (CA 0795465); in OK, AIS Affinity Insurance Services, Inc.; in CA, Aon Affinity Insurance Services, Inc., (CA 0G94493), Aon Direct Insurance Administrators and Berkely Insurance Agency and in NY, AIS Affinity Insurance Agency.