Bookmark and Share

Special Edition Legal Case Study


Healthcare Professionals and Medical Malpractice: A Case Study with Risk Management Strategies

Medical malpractice claims can be asserted against any healthcare provider. Although there may be a perception that physicians are held responsible for the majority of lawsuits, the reality is that healthcare professionals, including physical therapists, pharmacists and counselors are more frequently finding themselves defending the care they provide.


Physical Therapist Edition

Case Study: Overly Aggressive Treatment

This case involves a 42-year old female with a long history of bilateral knee injuries and subsequent surgeries. She received her first surgery at age 14 to her right knee and then both knees at ages 16, 18, 21 and then again at 40... Read the Full Case with Risk Management Recommendations

Pharmacist Edition

Case Study: Failure to Monitor

In this case, the defendant pharmacist was employed by a home infusion pharmacy where he was the head pharmacist and also was appointed director of pharmacy. The home infusion company provided home health care to patients, including the dispensing and administration of oral and parenteral medications, nursing care, personal care services and case management... Read the Full Case with Risk Management Recommendations

Counselor Edition

Case Study: Inappropriate Behavior and Sexual Misconduct by Counselor

The defendant was a licensed mental health counselor in solo practice who treated the client (a 51-year-old married woman) for multiple issues over approximately a two-year period. The client's intake form stated she was seeking treatment for problems in her marriage, symptoms related to being an adult child of an alcoholic, co-dependency and difficulties with communication. The defendant treated the client both separately and in couples' therapy sessions with her husband... Read the Full Case with Risk Management Recommendations




May 2010 Legal Case Study



Man Claims Vicodin Over-Prescribed for Over a Decade - Liver Damage Requires Liver Transplant - $1.425 Million Arbitration Award.

The plaintiff was prescribed Vicodin from 1990 to 2006 by orthopedic surgeon. The plaintiff had undergone surgery on his leg as a teenager which required a prosthesis. The prosthesis migrated out of his femur over time, causing pain and the Vicodin was prescribed for the pain.

At one point, a pharmacist told the plaintiff that his prescriptions could not be refilled as often as he was bringing them in.

The defendant maintained that the plaintiff was given a prescription to an outside pharmacy because he claimed that he could not endure the lengthy lines at the pharmacy, but then filled both the pharmacy prescription and the outside prescription.

The plaintiff claimed that he developed liver failure from the Vicodin and underwent a liver transplant. The plaintiff claimed that he had been prescribed an excessive amount of Vicodin.

The defendant maintained that the plaintiff had been encouraged to undergo pain management therapy, but had refused. The defendant also claimed that the pharmacist and an outside pharmacist had warned the plaintiff of the dangers of taking more than the prescribed amount of Vicodin.

The defendant maintained that the plaintiff had taken the medication for years without problems and must have taken a much larger dose at one time to cause the liver failure.

According to a published account a $1,425,000 arbitration award was given.

With permission from Medical Malpractice Verdicts, Settlements & Experts; Lewis Laska, Editor, 901 Church St., Nashville, TN 37203-3411, 1-800-298-6288.

Search the Archives

By Topic
By Keyword