Special Edition Legal Case Study
Healthcare Professionals and Medical Malpractice: A Case Study with Risk Management Strategies
Medical malpractice claims can be asserted against any healthcare provider. Although there may be a perception that physicians are held responsible for the majority of lawsuits, the reality is that healthcare professionals, including physical therapists, pharmacists and counselors are more frequently finding themselves defending the care they provide.
Case Study: Therapy for Back Pain caused Injury
The defendant physical therapist owns a private practice whose specialty is treatment of orthopedic conditions. Initially, the patient (plaintiff), a 55 year-old male, received physical therapy from the defendant physical therapist following his total knee replacement. A year later, the patient was referred to the defendant physical therapist for treatment of his back pain. Approximately two years later, the patient contacted the defendant physical therapist to request consultation for his on-going back pain. Read the Full Case with Risk Management Recommendations
Read Previous Issues of the HPSO Special Edition Legal Case Study: Physical Therapist Edition
Case Study: Failure to refer patient to a physician, failure to counsel patient on medication uses and expectations, inflating a patient's expectations through false advertising, publishing false marketing material
A 42 year-old male patient (plaintiff) went to the defendant pharmacist's pharmacy for what seemed to be a bite or sore on the back of his leg. The area of concern was hard, blackish, painful in the center and had different shades of red around it. The patient advised the defendant pharmacist that he first noticed the area the prior evening when it was only a small red spot. Upon the defendant pharmacist's inspection of the patient's leg, the patient alleges that the pharmacist assessed the area as a brown recluse spider bite and stated "he had just the thing". Read the Full Case with Risk Management Recommendations
Read Previous Issues of the HPSO Special Edition Legal Case Study: Pharmacist Edition
September 2008 Legal Case Study
|Man Claims No Physical Therapy Personnel Were Nearby When Electrical Stimulation Machine Caused Electrical Shock - $50,000 Settlement With Machine Manufacturer - $1.46 Million Verdict Against Others.|
The plaintiff, age forty-seven, was undergoing physical therapy in June 2002 with the use of an electrical stimulation machine. The machine had an emergency stop cable attached, which allowed a patient to quickly stop it in an emergency. During the plaintiff’s session, the physical therapist left him unattended. While the therapist was away the plaintiff believed he experienced an electrical shock. In a panic, he shouted for one or two minutes, but no one responded. When the physical therapist finally entered the room the plaintiff was partially unresponsive. The plaintiff had undergone the same treatment without difficulty three days earlier.
The plaintiff alleged post-traumatic stress disorder and pain disorder, which resulted from his emotional conversion disorder. The plaintiff claimed that a therapist should have remained within audible range of him at all times and if that had been done he would have been heard. The plaintiff also alleged that the clinic failed to provide him with the emergency stop cable.
The defendants contended that the physical therapist’s aide and physical therapist were within audible range and came to the plaintiffs aide immediately. The clinic claimed that it was not it policy to provide the emergency stop cable because the machine had multiple built-in safety redundancies which would prevent it from emitting excess electrical currents. The clinic also claimed that the cable was there and was plugged in. The defendants also claimed that there were no neurological findings of any injury.
According to a published account, the manufacturer of the electrical stimulation machine settled for $50,000 prior to trial. A jury returned a $1,461,532 verdict against all the defendants. Post-trial motions were pending.
Search the Archives
Recently Posted Legal Case Studies
|Physician Gives Woman Prescriptions for Diflucan and Percocet at Same Time, Intending Woman to Take Percocet Later -Woman Fills Prescriptions at Same Time Without Warning From Pharmacy - Death From Taking Them at the Same Time - Defense Verdict|
|Woman Claims Fall During Transfer From Bed to Wheelchair for Physical Therapy - Fractured Hip - Defendants Deny Fall Occurred and Claim Woman Suffered Pathologic Fracture Related to Osteodystrophy From Kidney Failure – Defense Verdict|
|Failure to Properly Monitor Woman Taking Reglan - Tardive Dyskinesia - $250,000 Settlement|
|Nephrologist Writes Prescription for Potassium For Woman On Dialysis Which Was Not Clear and Was Interpreted at a High Dosage - Nurses and Pharmacist Don't Follow-up on Hospital Computer's Notation of a Need for Confirmation|
|Woman With Multiple Sclerosis Claims Failure to Provide Protection From Falls During Therapy - Therapist Opens Door On to Woman, Causing Fall and Fractures - Defense Verdict|
|Local Pharmacy's Pharmacist Accesses Woman's Prescription History Because Woman Had Previously Dated Her Husband and She Suspected Transmission of STD - Pharmacist Tells Husband, Who Then Texts Woman With Details of Her Prescription History|
|EMTs Determine Premature Baby to be Non-Viable Without Checking for Heart Beat - Baby Determined to be Alive Upon Arrival at Hospital - Death Before Two Months of Age Due to Lack of Oxygen - $1 Million Settlement.|
|Phlebotomist Performing Physical Exam for Insurance Application Allegedly Causes Median Nerve Injury - Man Develops Complex Regional Pain Syndrome -$5 Million Gross Verdict.|
|Man Suffering From Anxiety and Other Issues Agrees to Hospital Transport, Then Decides Not To Go To Hospital When Ambulance Arrives at Hospital|
|Teenager Diagnosed with Molluscum Contagiosum and Prescribed Verr-Canth to be Used at Home - Defendant Admits Fault, but Claims Pharmacy's Actions Were Intervening Cause - Pharmacy Settled for Undisclosed Amount-$3.5 Million Gross Verdict|
|Woman Given Prescription for 100 Milligram Dosage of Phenergan Which Was Filled By Pharmacy Despite Claims That Prescribing Physician Called to Cancel Prescription Due to Dosage Error - Resulting in Lingering Tinnitus - $1.4 Million Verdict|
|Failure to Provide Proper Support to Woman During Physical Therapy Blamed for Fall and Death - Physical Therapists Claim She Slid From Bed and Was Lowered to Floor - $1,158,392 Verdict|